
In order to best shamelessly pander to my video-gaming cohorts in the confectionary exchange, I decided that a two pronged approach was necessary. In addition to appealing to their gullet, I also needed to appeal to their hearts. This was necessary if I wanted to maintain the illusion that I know what I’m doing in a kitchen. Therefore, in addition to making the spectacularly un-photogenic but quite delicious world peace cookies and chocolate toffee cookies , I also made a batch of TF2 themed cookies based on the much coveted hats.
I started with the Cooks Illustrated rolled butter cookie, butterscotch variation.
1/2 pound (2 sticks) unsalted butter, softened
1 cup packed light brown sugar
1/2 tsp salt
1 large egg plus 1 yolk
2 teaspoons vanilla extract
2.5 cups all purpose flour
Cream the butter, sugar, and salt until airy and fluffy. Beat in the yolk and then the egg and vanilla. When well mixed, add flour and mix at slow speed until just combined. Divide into 4 pieces and wrap in plastic wrap and refrigerate until firm, at least 1 hour.
I seem to have more trouble than most when actually rolling these out, which may be because I live in Southern California and preheating the oven just warms the kitchen up too much to make this easy. The best solution I found was to let the dough firm up and roll it out into sheets 1/8 inch thick and re-refrigerate in sheet form. After 20 minutes, I cut out the cookies and don’t have to wrestle with flaccid dough.
For these cookies I used a cutter about 2.5″ in diameter, which were done in 8 minutes at 375° F.
Let cookies cool completely before icing.
Icing
makes 2.5 cups, which is a little more than needed for the amount of cookies made with the above recipe
4 cups of royal icing sugar (you can substitute confectioner’s sugar and add 1/2 tsp vanilla extract)
2 egg whites
1/2 tsp cream of tartar (found in the spice section of the grocery store, not the baking section)
2 teaspoons water
Everything I learned about royal icing I learned from Sweetopia, so your best bet is to follow her tutorial. I had a hard enough time wrangling a piping bag and royal icing without stopping to take pictures. She’s a pro.
Beat all ingredients with a mixer at slow speed until combined, then beat at medium speed until stiff peaks form. Slowly add in more water by the teaspoon until you get icing that regains a smooth surface in about 5-10 seconds when the surface is disturbed. Using a number 2 piping tip, make just the circular outline for each cookie. Let harden. Your first cookies will be ready to be flooded about the time you finish the last cookie.
Dilute the royal icing for the flooding by adding in a few more drops of water. Quickly zig-zag over the interior of the cookie and fill it in as best you can. Gently shake the cookie to redistribute the icing and make a smooth, even surface. Use a toothpick to pop any large air bubbles that form. Your cookie surfaces should be nice and shiny.
Let cookies dry overnight. Because I’m a wuss, I didn’t draw the hats on using more royal icing. I just used these food coloring pens. I practiced sketching out the hats that I wanted to draw and then took the ugliest cookie and started drawing. The colors do have a tendency to bleed into each other, your best bet is to draw outlines and then fill in later.
Heed my warning and package these carefully as the icing is fairly brittle. At least one package of my beloved hats arrived with some reassembly required.

from: ronnie
to: GabeN@valvesoftware.com
date: Sat, Oct 3, 2009 at 7:57 PM
subject: I made TF2 hat pack cookies.
They are butterscotch flavored. Unfortunately, all you will be
receiving is a batch of flare guns and a jar of pee.
Love,
Ronnie
Attached Image: IMG_1414-1.jpg
——————-
from: GabeN
to: ronnie
cc: Robin Walker <Robin@valvesoftware.com>
subject: RE: I made TF2 hat pack cookies.
I’d rather have the cookies.